Gout Forum : Can you massage your joint to break down crystals?

Enter your email address:

All new gout forum messages
delivered to your inbox.
Or subscribe in a reader

Read & Learn …

Welcome to GoutPal’s Gout Forum. Anyone can post here – there is no need to register, though I can’t see why you wouldn’t all you need to do is register.

Registration is free.

    Please read the gout forum guidelines before posting.

If you want to find answers quickly, please try this search:

… Or Post & Learn Even More

“Every time you respond to someone here, more people see the helpfulness, and they are encouraged to contribute. First with questions, but then with advice and support. It is a wonderful thing to see, and be part of. The diversity of views is very special, and I feel that this is only achievable through continuing natural growth”

This is the kind of spirit unique only to Gout Pal Interactive!

You must be logged in to post Login Register

Can you massage your joint to break down crystals?

UserPost

10:57 pm
January 14, 2010


davidk

Toe Torture (status changes after 50 posts)

posts 50

I find soaking my toes in a hot bath brings some relief.  A couple times I have massaged the toe joint and it felt like perhaps I was able to break up the crystals a bit.  Not sure if that can really happen or if I imagined it.  So, my questions are: 1) can you really break down the crystals by manually massaging the joint? 2) if so, should you? Would that help break it down and assist in the process or is it doing more harm than good?Confused


Along these same lines, I saw links here or somewhere else on the internet about “gout exercise”, but never could find the actual info.  My toes have been swelled up and mostly unable to bend for 8 weeks now and sometimes I wonder if some of the stiffness is from atrophy of the muscles as much as it is from crystals.  I try to move them around some but the gout pain limits me.  Is there a point where you should be trying to move the joints or massage them or anything?  (Some days I can't put any weight on either big toe; some days, I can put some weight, but cannot bend the toe up – meaning, the very last part of the step when walking is too painful, so I use a cane and take short steps and walk with a stiff/straight back and most of my weight on my heels).


I'm on UA lowering meds as well as colchicine for the short term and know I need those meds to actually cure the gout, but wondering if this massaging can also add any benefit while I work to get the UA levels down and the crystals and trophi dissolving.  (I'm on high dose prednisone and low dose colchicine (can't tolerate more than .3 mg 2 x / day) and that seems to keep the edge off the extreme toe pain, but I haven't been able to get the pain and swelling down enough to walk even close to normal and this has been every day for 8 weeks now). (Just started on the UA  a week ago and seeing a rheumatologist in a week for the first time, so I am pretty hopeful it will get better over the coming weeks).

7:41 am
January 15, 2010


zip2play

Member

posts 1213

I like the idea of hot water soaks becasue urate is much more soluble at higher temperatures. Probably heavy socks and gloves for sleeping is wise to prevent the extremities chilling overnight.


As for massaging the joints…I think it might be a bad idea because, no, you will not break up crystals, but, yes, you might break up their covering, expose many, and get a worse attack. Tendons inflamed by uric acid and the immune system attack really need to be treated gently.

The UPSIDE of your attack is that if it were in the full fury of podagra you wouldn't be able to TOUCH you toes, much less wiggle them around.Wink


I hope the UA lowering med kicks in for you soon.

12:27 pm
January 15, 2010


Tavery

Swollen Joints

Seattle Region

posts 70

Massaging causes more problems than it helps.


The problems with massaging are:

  1. Uric crystals are sharp pointy spear shapes. Massaging them means pushing those spears into the surrounding tissue causing inflamation and tiny but physical damage.
  2. Uric crystals are sharp pointy spear shapes. Massaging the crystals will also cause them to break apart into smaller pieces and form a compacted mass of crystals that prevent bloodflow from getting to them. (i.e. slower to dissolve
  3. Check out a picture of what uric acid crystals look like… http://www.hopkins-arthritis.o…..ystals.jpg

Heat therapy is a more debatable topic – though I fall on the “for” side of the debate. Sitting in a hot tub or soaking your feet in a hot foot bath can cause crystals to dissolve since you only have to raise the internal temperature a couple degrees to make them soluable.

Upside: Crystals dissolve. Increased bloodflow helps move the liquid uric acid out of the area. If your uric acid level is low then it can help flush it from your system.

Downside: Crystals reform when your temp returns to normal. Increased bloodflow can also help the uric acid delve deeper into joints and other areas. Can cause a flareup if your uric acid suddenly spikes higher.

If you are Allopurinol and your normal level is sub-5.0 then doing regular heat therapy might help eliminate the lingering crystals in your joints. My personal unexpert opinion is that 20-30 minutes in the jacuzzi every couple days is not only relaxing, but helps my gout.

12:24 pm
January 17, 2010


davidk

Toe Torture (status changes after 50 posts)

posts 50

Thanks Zip and Tavery. I appreciate the sound advice.  Jacuzzi soaks stay in; massaging is out.  I also ice my feet a couple times a day and that helps relieve pain quite a bit.

1:59 am
January 18, 2010


trev

Tophi Terror

England

posts 749

It might be worth trying 1/2 cup of Soda bicarb &/or Epsom Salts in the soak water.

I've found this helpful and the water can be kept in the bowl for re-use in short spells- even if at room temp.

11:56 am
January 18, 2010


odo

Tophi Terror

London UK

posts 126

davidk said:

Thanks Zip and Tavery. I appreciate the sound advice.  Jacuzzi soaks stay in; massaging is out.  I also ice my feet a couple times a day and that helps relieve pain quite a bit.


Yeah, icing definitely a bad idea; as you know, the effect is only temporary and you're more likely to make things worse by forming new crystals which don't dissolve when your feet return to normal temperature Surprised

10:10 am
January 19, 2010


zip2play

Member

posts 1213

Yep,


I am definitely anti-icing as well. Heat is the gouty's friend.

6:13 am
January 20, 2010


GoutPal

Admin

Baildon, Yorkshire

posts 1171

I appreciate the reminder about the perils of icing. I had hoped to have new reference pages for gout treatments finished by now, but in the meantime, I've done a quick edit on the old gout pain treatments page.


Now all we need to do is get the authorities to rethink their advice!

Unless replying to specific points in this topic, please start a new topic. See new topic link above, or gout forum guidelines.
Current gout status in my profile.

5:55 pm
January 22, 2010


davidk

Toe Torture (status changes after 50 posts)

posts 50

thank you all for your excellent advice.  I really did not want to hear that I should not be using ice.  I'd been using it a couple times a day for weeks and getting good temporary relief.  In fact, I had my two ice packs in hand and was heading up to bed when I decided to check any new posts on gout-pal.  But you guys on gout pal have had nothing but good advice, so I put the ice back and put heat on my toes.  Nothing but heat for the last couple days.  I also recently started on Uloric and have dropped from 9.1 UA to 4.4 in just two weeks of Uloric 40mg.  Smile  Toes are feeling a little better today than they have in weeks and I'm very encouraged.  Thanks!

10:09 am
January 23, 2010


zip2play

Member

posts 1213

With that nice drop from 9.1 to 4.4 you'll be back to normal very soon. And the Uloric will keep you there.

1:11 am
May 18, 2010


monaco

Toe Torture (status changes after 50 posts)

posts 21

I often come out of a hot bath or hot shower with red and swelled up big toe joint (even if my toe felt completely fine and was skin color before hand).  Does this mean the crystals were dissolved and just waiting to be flushed out?  When the foot returns to normal temperature the color goes back to normal, I assume the crystals were not flushed out and just re-formed.


I'm also curious, if heat can make the uric acid crystals more soluable and dissolve, what would be the best way to get those crystals up your leg and out your body?


About the Gout Pal Interactive forum

Most Users Ever Online:

64


Currently Online:

17 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 12

Topics: 777

Posts: 6852

Membership:

There are 1066 Members

There have been 320 Guests

There is 1 Admin

There is 1 Moderator

Top Posters:

zip2play – 1213

trev – 749

vegetarianGuy – 358

cjeezy – 343

Utubelite – 272

metamorph – 213

Administrators: GoutPal (1171 Posts)

Moderators: GoutPal (1171 Posts)




Switch to our mobile site

Keith Taylors Facebook Profile
Please follow my blog on Facebook
If you want to find gout answers quickly, please use this search: To search beyond GoutPal:

© Copyright Keith Taylor 2006 - 2009